Quote from: gordonblu on Thu, 20 Jun 2013, 00:30
I thought the way Jonathan Kent died was one of the stupidest plot points I've seen in a long time. I don't care if Jonathan thought the world wasn't ready for Kal, rescuing his adopted father surely should have been worth the risk and only gave this version of Supes more "angst". His chastising Clark for rescuing the school bus was also overtly harsh.
As a devoted Reeve fan I was surprised how much I enjoyed the film in the end. I don't think it's the best nor definitive Superman movie though. And several things bothered me but still had a great time watching it.
But yes this death of Johnathan Kent scene did not convince me at all. I guess it's wrong to compare this with Donner's 1978 original but that death scene of Johnathan (played by Glenn Ford) is still just so brilliant and a good example at proving in this case the Reeve films can and do still outclass this newer film in numerous ways. I love the fact it's something as simple as a heart attack that takes him from Clark's life (and something that Clark with all his powers and lack of experience cannot prevent). Having recently lost my own father (himself a massive Superman fan) it's amazing how much you relate to a believable, beautifully shot scene like this when you do finally experience a loss in that way.
I found it quite strange therefore in the way they disposed of him this time. Largely because Nolan, Snyder and Goyer have gone on and on and on about this being a far more grounded, realistic film than any previous Superman films. Yet when Johnathan is taken by the tornado he is gracefully consumed by the swirling cyclone in almost a ghost-like disappearing act. Elegantly shot material for film but realism? Er well. I mean who would stand there in real life and allow themselves to be taken in a situation like that? Wouldn't you not be screaming in terror as you realize your life is about to end? Isn't that not realism Mr Goyer? I just thought it was a moment that betrayed all their over-spoken intentions.